Log In. Definition of the human condition. Learn More about the human condition. Share the human condition Post the Definition of the human condition to Facebook Share the Definition of the human condition on Twitter. Resources for the human condition Time Traveler: Explore other words from the year the human condition first appeared Time Traveler! Explore the year a word first appeared. Dictionary Entries near the human condition the House of Lords the House of Representatives the human animal the human condition the human race the hump the hurdles. Statistics for the human condition Look-up Popularity.
Comments on the human condition What made you want to look up the human condition? Get Word of the Day daily email! Diener Lecture Fund. Richard J. Estes Lecture Fund. Alex C. Michalos Lecture Fund. Endowed Tracks Ronald E. Anderson Endowed Track.
KANEKO Human Condition - KANEKO
Elizabeth Eckermann Endowed Track. Takashi Inoguchi Endowed Track.
Kenneth C. Land Endowed Track. Mahar Mangahas Endowed Track. Rhonda G. Phillips Endowed Track. Joseph Sirgy Endowed Track.
Awards All Awards. Award for the Betterment of the Human Condition. Research Fellow Award. Young Scholar Award. John's wort as a treatment for depression illustrates my thesis. A recent carefully controlled study found negative results for St. John's wort as a treatment for major depression, and the investigators suggested that previous studies with more favorable results had significant design flaws 5.
I further suggest that one component of the faulty design was that some of the subjects fell within the gray area I have been discussing and would have felt better within a reasonable period with or without medication. Are all high-strung "nervous" people the victims of an affliction labeled generalized anxiety disorder? And can we reliably distinguish the rambunctiousness and distractibility of many boys from attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder?
Among the personality disorders—a general category itself of somewhat doubtful validity—the gray area includes the following dichotomies: paranoid personality disorder versus a suspicious turn of mind, schizoid personality disorder versus a preference for solitude, avoidant personality disorder versus a mild to moderate sensitivity to rejection, and narcissistic personality disorder versus a tendency to be self-centered and to show off.
Finally, can we agree with the Surgeon General that one-fifth of the American people are in need of mental health treatments, without having to ask the same question I have quoted about depression? Does such a figure cast a shadow on the validity of the concept of mental illness itself and lend credence to those like Thomas Szasz 6 who claim that "mental illness" exists only as a social construct?
- Our Journey Across the World;
- Download this book to print or read offline?
- 366 Pensieri per un Anno Diverso (Italian Edition).
- A Journal of Economics, Culture & Society.
The framers of the DSM and many psychiatrists would support the claim that conscientious adherence to DSM criteria will protect from the dangers and confusions I have described. This claim has merit—the criteria serve to delineate and define most psychiatric disorders and to differentiate them from each other in a way that is useful for diagnosis and treatment. However, I believe that the application of DSM criteria to the borderline areas I have been discussing is limited by two basic weaknesses. The first is that no subjective checklist of a patient's history and complaints can infallibly separate clinical syndromes that qualify as disorders from various kinds of human discomfort of lesser intensity.
What is needed and what is still lacking is some kind of biological marker, such as tissue alterations or a serologic or imaging abnormality, that can distinguish, say, a clinical depression from a state of unhappiness. Such biological markers are available in other branches of medicine but not in psychiatry, except to a very limited degree. It is also true that most people who have depression, clinical or not, have other problems and concerns that affect their feelings and will influence the criteria by which they are diagnosed. Second, the motivations and experience of the diagnosing psychiatrist must be taken into account in cases in which the clinical picture is equivocal.
An important incentive for making a DSM diagnosis is to qualify the patient for insurance reimbursement, which is otherwise unavailable.
- The Human Condition III.
- My Journey;
- Murder At The Gate of Welcome (Detective Shvili Book 1);
- New Pursuits - A Sexy African-American Erotic Short Story from Steam Books.
- Janine Does the Dean - An Erotic Short.
Another incentive might be to justify prescribing a drug rather than taking a primarily psychotherapeutic approach when a psychiatrist is skilled in the former but not the latter modality. Other, less obvious but significant motivations may play a role.
The Human Condition I
To summarize my thesis, I believe that in pursuing the Holy Grail of remedicalization, psychiatry has corrected an error in one direction but has gone too far in the other. The result has been not only the excessive emphasis on medical-model diagnosis but also a related "furor psychopharmacologus" 7 that seeks a specific drug for every aberrant feeling or behavior as if we were in quest of a society tranquilized by "Soma" as in the dystopia described in Aldous Huxley's Brave New World 8.
Another consequence has been the downgrading of psychotherapy except when it is used in conjunction with drug treatment. Patients who seek psychotherapy often experience what can be called "problems of living," which are defined as conditions that produce psychopathological symptoms that are sufficient to negatively influence a person's well-being and relationships but not to justify a diagnosis of illness or disorder.
Such patients are often best treated with psychotherapy alone and not with drugs. Under the tyranny of "medical necessity," an outmoded and no longer effective gatekeeper, these patients must either pay for treatment out of pocket or be smuggled into insurance coverage by gaming the system with an inaccurate diagnosis, subjecting the therapist to moral risk 9 , This group of patients, sometimes rather patronizingly referred to as the "worried well," has constituted a component of my more than 50 years of practice and of the practices of colleagues, and we have helped many achieve beneficial results.
Rather than continue the charade I have described, the alternative course, as I see it, is for psychiatry to recognize and try to deal with the fact that ours is a profession that, while it has one foot firmly planted in medicine, is also deeply involved in other aspects of the human condition. To this extent it transcends the medical model.
The integrity of the profession of psychiatry as well as that of other helping professions such as psychology and social work that also now operate uneasily under the constraints of a sometimes inappropriate illness model depends on the acceptance of both aspects of this identity. Chodoff is in private practice and is clinical professor of psychiatry at George Washington University in Washington, D.